Tuesday, 16 November 2010

Tweckling, iconoclasm and lecturing as a normative discourse: reflections on two ALT-C keynotes

When I discovered what the topic of Donald Clark’s ALT-C keynote was I was pretty interested. ‘Don’t Lecture Me’ augured well, I thought, because challenging the orthodoxy of lecturing is a matter dear to my heart. But I honestly thought that this was going to be a classic example of preaching to the proverbial choir. Surely, I thought, settling into their seats in the auditorium were people, like me, who had read Bligh’s What’s the Use of Lectures? and Gibb’s ‘Twenty Terrible Reasons For Lecturing’ and were all going to enjoy the ride Clark was about to take us on. I couldn’t have been more wrong.

Before long, the twitter back channel started to fill with defensive and at times aggressive reactions to the points he was making. And these weren’t particularly radical points. These were points that have been made countless times before by countless other scholars in countless other settings over countless years. And I don’t say this out of disrespect for Clark’s scholarship. Clearly, it all still needs to be said. Again!


There were tweets attacking Clark for using a lecture to denounce lecturing, attacking him for critiquing the lecturers rather than the lecture, picking on physicists and his swearing and there were many more being just plain rude. I won’t counter these here as he’s done a perfectly good job of doing that himself in his blog and, as an old friend of mine would say, ‘he’s big enough to look after himself’.


What really struck me was that even here, at a teaching and learning technology conference, how many apparently well-informed, innovative thinkers about teaching and learning practice were defending the lecture as a pedagogic technique. Astonishingly, when I sent a tweet about this shock I was feeling I received two @ replies that, you guessed it, defended the lecture.


In his keynote Clark discussed lecturing as operating as a default. I would challenge him on this and argue that it is probably better understood as a normative discourse. A default is something to which things automatically reset or return. While I think this is true – I think there is more going on than this. I think lecturing operates, within HE, as a normative discourse. A normative discourse is a way of thinking and talking about something whereby it is understood to be true that something is normal. Heterosexuality is usually understood to operate as a normative discourse for instance – and this assumption is often referred to as heteronormativity. Similarly – in HE it is widely considered to be true that lecturing is normal. This is evident in our job titles, our institutional architecture, our workload models, our quality assurance strategies, our timetabling software and countless other systems and principles that define and demarcate our working lives.


One of the things about normative discourses is that they are really hard to talk against or to critique. Because something is seen as normal, saying anything which is critical of it can be taken personally by those who subscribe to this ‘truth’. That was what happened at the ALT-C keynote. While Clark was clearly critiquing the lecture as a pedagogical strategy, many people in the room who were engaging with the twitter back channel (and therefore probably many others who weren’t) clearly took his critique personally – as being an attack on them as lecturers and as people who had been lectured themselves as undergraduates.


Speaking out against the lecture is hard. Bligh, for instance, spends the first chapter of his book arguing why lecturing is not a great pedagogical strategy and then spends the rest of the book suggesting ways we could do it better. Gibbs’ ‘Twenty Terrible Reasons For Lecturing’ is written explicitly in response to the defences lecturers routinely offer of the lecture (and by extension of themselves). I hear these defences all too frequently myself when I muster the courage to challenge the normative discourse and Gibbs’ article comes in really handy at these moments.


In effect, speaking out against lecturing is hard because it amounts to a kind of iconclasm – literally icon smashing. As Clark’s subsequent blog post made clear, he is big enough to look after himself. I still can’t help thinking he must have felt at least a little bruised by the experience. Which leaves me wondering about those without his confidence and self-employed status. And this is precisely how normative discourses maintain and protect themselves – it becomes too risky and too scary to speak out against them so people choose not to and the ‘truth’ of the normalcy gets to sail on calmly.


What really drilled the point home to me were the tweets which saw the second keynote delivered by Dr Sugata Mitra as incontrovertible evidence that the lecture isn’t dead. While I agree with them all that it was a fantastic example of a brilliant, inspiring, spell-binding lecture, so was Clark’s. (A key point that Gibbs makes very effectively is that inspiring lectures aren’t in and of themselves evidence of the effectiveness of lecturing as a pedagogical strategy). What these tweeters failed to see, however, was that Mitra, like Clark was arguing persuasively and passionately about the ineffectiveness of teacher-centred learning strategies – at the core of which is lecturing. At one point he said something to the effect that students learn better when teachers aren’t even in the room! In essence, Mitra’s critique of lecturing was as powerful and passionate (albeit with fewer swear words) thank Clark’s but he escaped without the at times brutal tweckling simply because he wasn’t being so directly and overtly iconoclastic.


To view to the keynotes at the ALT-C YouTube channel, go here:

Donald Clark's 'Don't Lecture Me'

Sugata Mitra's 'The Hole in the Wall: Self Organising Systems'


To view them with the twitter backchannel as subtitles, (with thanks to Martin Hawksey for pointing these out) go here:

Donald Clark's 'Don't Lecture Me'

Sugata Mitra's 'The Hole in the Wall: Self-Organising Systems'

31 comments:

  1. Thanks for this considered response. I was beginning to think that academia was populated by Twitter loving reactionaries who have forsaken debate for adolescent abuse! Your point about normative discourse is, of course, spot on. What is odd is that the practitioners within HE are still trapped in this normative cage. You also make the very good point that Mitra was far more radical in his prescriptions than me, but he avoids the dirct challenge. Not at all bruised as I've been doing this for years. Indeed heartened by the subsequent feedback and YouTube figures. I made the point that online is better because it's scalable, and that has come to pass. Thanks again for the thoughtful post.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks for your comment Donald. I too am pleased to see the response your keynotes have received on YouTube and hope to spread the news of their availability further through my blog. Keep up the good iconoclastic work!

    ReplyDelete
  3. This is a wonderful reflection and I lovreally like the association you've made between Donald's and Sugata's keynotes.

    It's really interesting to see how Twitter is being used almost to make what was once a person's internal monologue explicit. Steve Wheeler has a nice post on this area here http://steve-wheeler.blogspot.com/2009/12/weapon-of-mass-distraction.html

    It will be interesting to see if we are still in a disruptive phase of this technology or if this is the new parlance.

    For your readers who didn't experience the keynotes with the Twitter backchannel they can be relived from the links at the bottom of this post http://www.rsc-ne-scotland.org.uk/mashe/2010/11/ititle-altc2010/

    Martin

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thanks Martin - and particular for the heads up about the twitter-subtitled videos of the keynotes. I'll stick that link into the blog.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Great reflections Cath.....the Sugata lecture is a very polished and consistently delivered performance, refined like an Eddie Izzard gig. I have seen it many times and it still inspires. Is it really a lecture? I was also shocked by the defensive and , on occasion,arrogant and rude, reaction. I await with interest the outcome of the HEFCE review of Jisc!

    ReplyDelete
  6. This blog posting was quite like a lecture. I quite like lectures myself, especially good ones. It always seemed to me that I could learn much more quickly in a lecture than by other methods (particularly lab work). Being quite busy, i had to take my teaching-and-learning unit's word that other techniques like were more effective, particularly ones that took account of the learning styles of the students. Imagine my surprise when I find out that there is no evidence to support this theory (http://voices.washingtonpost.com/answer-sheet/daniel-willingham/-my-guest-today-is.html). So what am I to do? As a working teacher I need the advice of the experts. Could it be that they are prone to following fads and fashions? Sorry guys, next time you advise me on how to change my teaching, please bring along the evidence. I'll stick with what works for me until it is proven to me that something else works better.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Thanks for this informative post! I really appreciated it :) cafe24 article extension

    ReplyDelete
  8. It seems suspect to assume that the same, undesirable behaviors that are part of human nature, should not be present in a digital space. You don't address bad behavior by closing things down or turning them off- you confront and call people on it, like neighbors on their porches.
    http://essayswriters.org/paper-writing/

    ReplyDelete
  9. Buy cheap adult animal onesies and character onesies from hotonesie.com at cheap prices. We offer a wide range of cheap adult onesies and kigurumis.
    mens onesie
    Minion Onesies
    minion pajamas

    ReplyDelete
  10. Anytime circumstances acquire tough and you only ought to have closed in funds, getting some type of Principle Loan from the bank is that the simplest kind of mortgage to suit your wishes. You acquire the money you can need; you retain the automotive and in addition all of us merely facilitate the actual subject to the automobile before the disposition decisions can on the face of it be settled whole, where by celebration nstallment loan elgin this type of subject will on the face of it be came back in your case free of charge and in addition evident. It extraordinarily is with such ease.

    ReplyDelete
  11. seorang istri lebih menginginkan ketika hubungan suami istri sama pasangannya bisa lebih puas dengan ereksi yang lebih keras, kencang dan juga tahan lama, seorang dokter lebih menganjurkan anda untuk meminum obat kuat herbal alami yang ampuh mengatasi lemah syahwat dan ejakulasi dini serta bisa menyembuhkan secara total.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Make sure you might have covered all of the major parts of the essay inside your outline as introduction, body in addition to conclusion when you actually begin writing this essay. Ensure you have covered all of the major parts of the essay inside your outline as introduction, body in addition to conclusion when you actually begin writing this essay. custom essay writing services

    ReplyDelete
  13. To find out which in the lenders are generally best within your area which enable it to completely attend to your family needs, read critiques and boards car title loans montgomery Ask individuals concerning his or her suffers from with your economic providers and assemble important info about the lenders.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Auto title credits are equipped for giving you the sum up to 5000 dollars for the reimbursement time of 3-7 years. You must pay back the acquired sum on its expected date. Something else, your auto title will be usurped by the bank and you won't have the capacity to utilize your auto any longer.auto title loans chicago

    ReplyDelete
  15. Owning a bicycle is a rush, which is discovering a lot of resurgent advance among individuals over the world today. With worldwide fuel costs hinting at no halting their upward pattern at any point in the near future, numerous individuals have decided on the fervor of biking as an option. Payday Loans Chicago

    ReplyDelete
  16. I am a private loan lender which have all take to be a genuine lender i give out the best loan to my client at a very convenient rate.The interest rate of this loan is 3%.i give out loan to public and private individuals.the maximum amount i give out in this loan is $1,000,000.00 USD why the minimum amount i give out is 5000.for more information

    Your Full Details:
    Full Name :………
    Country :………….
    state:………….
    Sex :………….
    Address............
    Tel :………….
    Occupation :……..
    Amount Required :…………
    Purpose of the Loan :……..
    Loan Duration :…………
    Phone Number :………
    Mobile Number: +919910768937
    Contact Email osmanloanserves@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  17. Salah satu eksotisme gunung bromo yang sangat menarik perhatian para wisatawan ada hamparan lautan pasir berbisik di gunung bromo. Di titik wisata ini anda bisa menunggangi kuda sewaan milik penduduk lokal hanya dengan biaya 10.000 rupiah. Info paket wisata gunung bromo dari kota malang dan surabaya baca info disini.

    Elf short yang berkapasitas 12 seat menjadi mobil primadona di kota malang untuk perjalanan wisata di malang batu. Banyak tempat jasa penyewaan mobil elf short di malang yang bertarif murah dan sangat cocok di kantong backpacker. Selengkapnya sewa mobil elf short di malang klik tautan blog.

    Mobil jenis innova di kota surabaya banyak yang disewakan karena memang permintaan rental mobil innova di surabaya sangatlah tinggi. Harga sewa innova ini sangatlah terjangkau oleh berbagai kalangan. Selain itu kelebihan dari mengendarai innova ini sangatlah nyaman jika dibandingkan dengan mobil sejenis. Tempat kantor sewa mobil jenis innova di surabaya detail disini.

    Rental mobil elf di jogja yang berkapasitas bisa memuat 15-20 orang sangatlah banyak. Jenis mobil elf ini adalah long yang rata-rata berisi 18 seat. Dengan menyewa mobil elf jogja ini bisa anda pergunakan untuk kepentingan keluarga atau jalan-jalan wisata. Tarif sewa mobil elf di jogja lirik blog ini.

    Jenis mobil avanza banyak disewakan di kota denpasar bali. Biasanya kantor pelayanan jasa penyewaan mobil di bali ini sudah include antar jemput ke bandara ngurah rai atau ke terminal di bali. Mobil avanza ini sangat nyaman dan berkapasitas 7 orang. Selengkapnya baca sewa mobil avanza di bali harga murah kunjungi link.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Hello Everybody,
    My name is Mrs Sharon Sim. I live in Singapore and i am a happy woman today? and i told my self that any lender that rescue my family from our poor situation, i will refer any person that is looking for loan to him, he gave me happiness to me and my family, i was in need of a loan of S$250,000.00 to start my life all over as i am a single mother with 3 kids I met this honest and GOD fearing man loan lender that help me with a loan of S$250,000.00 SG. Dollar, he is a GOD fearing man, if you are in need of loan and you will pay back the loan please contact him tell him that is Mrs Sharon, that refer you to him. contact Dr Purva Pius,via email:(urgentloan22@gmail.com) Thank you.

    BORROWERS APPLICATION DETAILS


    1. Name Of Applicant in Full:……..
    2. Telephone Numbers:……….
    3. Address and Location:…….
    4. Amount in request………..
    5. Repayment Period:………..
    6. Purpose Of Loan………….
    7. country…………………
    8. phone…………………..
    9. occupation………………
    10.age/sex…………………
    11.Monthly Income…………..
    12.Email……………..

    Regards.
    Managements
    Email Kindly Contact: urgentloan22@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  19. Ho sempre stato cinico nei confronti di persone che si sono lamentati di disgrazie vivendo. Ho usato per dire che non hanno un atteggiamento positivo e quello che anticipano viene a passare. "Come un uomo pensa, così è lui."clicca qui

    ReplyDelete
  20. Il dizionario E-C abitudini cerca-up costruire nella memoria, quindi anche una persona che non utilizzano dizionario E-C, il processo di traduzione avviene nella sua mente. Come risultato, il miglioramento della lingua inglese del lettore è fortemente ostacolato. Quindi, dizionario E-C deve essere evitato. scrivere il curriculum vitae inglese

    ReplyDelete
  21. L'impotenza può causare preoccupazione e bassa autostima, così come altri problemi in un rapporto. La buona notizia è, ci sono molte cure naturali impotenza che può davvero aiutare. Molte cure senza droga per problemi sessuali contribuirà a ridurre i problemi di stress, allo stesso tempo. clicca qui

    ReplyDelete
  22. Hello Everybody,
    My name is Mrs Sharon Sim. I live in Singapore and i am a happy woman today? and i told my self that any lender that rescue my family from our poor situation, i will refer any person that is looking for loan to him, he gave me happiness to me and my family, i was in need of a loan of S$250,000.00 to start my life all over as i am a single mother with 3 kids I met this honest and GOD fearing man loan lender that help me with a loan of S$250,000.00 SG. Dollar, he is a GOD fearing man, if you are in need of loan and you will pay back the loan please contact him tell him that is Mrs Sharon, that refer you to him. contact Dr Purva Pius,via email:(urgentloan22@gmail.com) Thank you.

    BORROWERS APPLICATION DETAILS


    1. Name Of Applicant in Full:……..
    2. Telephone Numbers:……….
    3. Address and Location:…….
    4. Amount in request………..
    5. Repayment Period:………..
    6. Purpose Of Loan………….
    7. country…………………
    8. phone…………………..
    9. occupation………………
    10.age/sex…………………
    11.Monthly Income…………..
    12.Email……………..

    Regards.
    Managements
    Email Kindly Contact: urgentloan22@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  23. It is one of the awesome site in my view as far as my knowledge is concerned about this kind website. Thanks for sharing!
    Packers And Movers Gurgaon

    ReplyDelete
  24. really a very nice blog i really appreciate all your efforts thank you so much for sharing this valuble information with all of us.
    Packers And Movers Gurgaon to Bhopal

    ReplyDelete

  25. I must say you had done a tremendous job,I appreciate all your efforts.Thanks alot for your writings......Waiting for a new 1...Please visit our wonderful and valuable website:
    Packers And Movers in Bangalore charges

    ReplyDelete